What's the difference between an Investment Policy Statement and a Risk Tolerance Questionnaire?

An Investment Policy Statement (IPS) and a Risk Tolerance Questionnaire are both important components in the field of investment management, but they serve different purposes. Let's explore the differences between the two:

Investment Policy Statement (IPS): An Investment Policy Statement (IPS) is a written document that outlines the guidelines and objectives for managing an investment portfolio. It is typically created by investment professionals or financial advisors in consultation with their clients. The IPS serves as a roadmap or guide for making investment decisions and provides a framework for the overall investment strategy. Here are some key features of an IPS:

  1. Objectives: The IPS defines the client's investment goals, which could include wealth preservation, capital appreciation, income generation, or a combination thereof. It sets clear objectives that the investment portfolio aims to achieve.

  2. Risk Tolerance: The IPS takes into account the client's risk tolerance, which is the client's willingness and ability to accept investment risk. Risk tolerance helps determine the asset allocation strategy, such as the mix of stocks, bonds, and other investments in the portfolio.

  3. Time Horizon: The IPS considers the client's investment time horizon, which refers to the length of time the investments are intended to be held. A longer time horizon may allow for a more aggressive investment strategy, while a shorter time horizon may require a more conservative approach.

  4. Asset Allocation: The IPS specifies the target asset allocation, outlining the desired percentages of various asset classes within the portfolio. It considers factors such as risk tolerance, investment objectives, and market conditions.

  5. Investment Guidelines: The IPS provides guidelines on permissible investment types, diversification requirements, risk management strategies, and any specific investment restrictions or exclusions.

Risk Tolerance Questionnaire: A Risk Tolerance Questionnaire is a tool used to assess an investor's comfort level with investment risk. It is typically a set of questions designed to gauge the individual's willingness and ability to tolerate fluctuations in investment values. The questionnaire helps determine the investor's risk profile and informs the investment decision-making process. Here are some key aspects of a Risk Tolerance Questionnaire:

  1. Risk Perception: The questionnaire seeks to understand how an individual perceives and reacts to investment risk. It may include questions about the investor's past experiences, reactions to market volatility, and financial goals.

  2. Risk Capacity: The questionnaire evaluates an individual's financial situation, including factors such as income, net worth, liabilities, and investment time horizon. These factors help determine the individual's capacity to take on investment risk.

  3. Risk Preference: The questionnaire assesses an individual's risk preference by asking about their willingness to accept different levels of risk for potentially higher returns. It may present scenarios or trade-offs to gauge the individual's comfort with potential losses or fluctuations.

  4. Risk Profile: Based on the responses, the questionnaire assigns the investor a risk profile, such as conservative, moderate, or aggressive. This profile helps guide the investment advisor in recommending suitable investment strategies and asset allocations.

While an IPS is a comprehensive document that guides the overall investment strategy, a Risk Tolerance Questionnaire is a tool used to assess an investor's risk profile and preferences. The IPS incorporates the information gathered from the questionnaire, along with other factors, to create a customized investment plan that aligns with the client's goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon.